1535 Wurtele Ave
Rare two-building income play in Algonquin (Churchill West, 40208). The main house is a 2-bed, 2-bath with a full basement, built in 1947, and converts easily to a 3-bed. A separate 800 sqft structure on the lot already has electric, water, and sewer, ready to finish as a 2-bed, 1-bath ADU. Run both and the property projects $2,800 a month in rent ($1,600 main plus $1,200 ADU). Finished ARV is about $220,000 ($150,000 main house plus $70,000 ADU). Renovated homes on Wurtele itself have sold from $135,000 to $165,000, and a turnkey 3-bed on nearby Algonquin Pkwy sold for $160,000 in May 2026. The second unit is what lifts this above a standard single-family exit. Offers start at $99,000, or Buy It Now at $110,000. $2,500 non-refundable EMD.
We Buy 502 is selling an equitable interest in a purchase contract, not a listed property. This is not an MLS listing. We Buy 502 is not acting as a real estate agent or broker in this transaction. The buyer is purchasing an assignment of contract directly from the contract holder. All information is believed accurate but not guaranteed — buyers are encouraged to perform their own due diligence prior to submitting an offer.
| Address | Sale Price | SqFt | Lot | $/SqFt | Cond | Sold |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 801 Algonquin Pkwy | $160,000 | 1,022 | — | $157 | A | May 2026 |
| Turnkey remodel (updated kitchen and bath, newer HVAC) on the Algonquin corridor in 40208. The strongest recent renovated comp and the anchor for the main-house value near $150,000. | ||||||
| 1412 Wurtele Ave ↗ | $135,000 | 1,019 | 5,401 sqft | $132 | A | Jul 2023 |
| Same block as the subject with a nearly identical footprint. Renovated with a quartz kitchen and a full finished basement. The closest location comp, and it supports the main house before adding any ADU income. | ||||||
| 1514 Wurtele Ave | $165,000 | 2,404 | — | $69 | — | Oct 2022 |
| A larger 3-bed / 3-bath on the same street. An older 2022 sale on more square footage, but it shows Wurtele topping out at $165,000 and brackets the high end of the block. | ||||||
